top of page

PCU PMA Blog

Writer's pictureAnubhav SInha

End Your Gut Feeling: Build your Product Capability from Opinion-Based to Evidence-Based

Updated: Jun 28, 2023



Introduction


In the past, product managers / people / decision makers, often made decisions based on their own opinions and gut feelings. Moreover, as the field of product management has evolved, there has been a growing thoughts on using an evidence-based approach to decision-making.

This shift towards evidence-based product management is due to a number of factors, including the increasing availability of data, the growing sophistication of data analysis tools, and the increasing demand for accountability from product managers.


Relying solely on gut feeling in product management can lead to misguided decisions and missed opportunities.

In this article you will find the importance of building a product management capability that is rooted in evidence-based practices. By transitioning from an opinion-based approach to an evidence-based product management approach, product managers and product people can enhance their decision-making process, drive better outcomes, and ultimately succeed in the ever-evolving business landscape.



The Limitations of Gut Feeling


While gut feeling can be a valuable tool for making decisions, it is important to remember that it is not always reliable. Gut feeling is often based on our own personal biases and previous experiences, which can lead us to make decisions that are not in the best interests of our users or our product as well as businesses.



For example, a product manager / people / technical person, might have a gut feeling that a new feature will be popular with users. However, if the product person does not have any data to support this gut feeling, it is possible that the feature will actually be a flop.


  1. Moving Beyond Assumptions: Opinion-based product management often relies on assumptions and personal beliefs about what customers want or need. In contrast, an evidence-based approach encourages product managers to seek empirical evidence and data-driven insights. By leveraging user research, market analysis, and data analytics, product managers can gain a more accurate understanding of customer needs, preferences, and behaviors, reducing reliance on assumptions and subjective opinions.

  2. Define Clear Goals and Metrics: Clearly define your product goals and identify the key metrics that will measure success. Aligning your decisions with specific goals and metrics will ensure that you focus on collecting relevant data and insights to support evidence-based decision-making.

  3. Mitigating Biases and Assumptions: Opinions can be influenced by personal biases, experiences, and preconceptions, leading to flawed decision-making. An evidence-based approach provides a framework for identifying and mitigating biases. By relying on objective data and rigorous analysis, product people can challenge their own assumptions, validate hypothesis, and can make decisions based on the most accurate information available.

  4. Overcoming Challenges and Limitations: Adopting an evidence-based approach in product management comes with its own set of challenges. Access to relevant and reliable data, implementation of effective measurement strategies, and interpretation of data can be complex tasks. However, the benefits outweigh the challenges.

  5. Improving your Product-Market Fit: Opinion-based product management often leads to a misalignment between the product and the target market. In contrast, an evidence-based approach enables product managers to validate assumptions, test hypotheses, and fine-tune product-market fit. By conducting thorough market research, user interviews, and usability testing, product managers can gather evidence that guides product development and ensures that the product meets real customer needs.


Think in this way to find out - is it really a problem or a Wishlist or your desire.


How you can build an Evidence-Based Product Management Capability?


There are a few steps involved in building an evidence-based product management capability. These ways may include:

  1. Identify the problem: The first step is to identify the problem that you are trying to solve. Think in this way to find out - is it really a problem or a Wishlist or your desire. This will help you to focus your research and data collection.

  2. Gather evidence: The next step is to gather evidence that is relevant to the problem. This evidence can come from a variety of sources, such as user research, market research, and competitive analysis.

  3. Evaluate the evidence: Once you have gathered evidence, you need to evaluate it. This involves critically examining the evidence to determine its quality and relevance.

  4. Make a decision: Once you have evaluated the evidence, you can make a decision. This decision should be based on the evidence and should be consistent with your goals and aligned to org objectives / product vision.



Conclusion


The shift towards evidence-based product management is a positive development, as it can lead to better products and more successful businesses. If oneself want to make better decisions as a product person, then you should consider using an evidence-based approach.


By building a product management capability rooted in evidence-based practices, product managers / people can minimize their biases, make more accurate decisions, and deliver products that truly meet customer needs.


Transitioning from an opinion-based approach to an evidence-based approach requires a commitment to data-driven methodologies, skill development, and cultivating a culture of evidence-based decision-making.




About the Author


Anubhav Sinha is a Co-founder as well as the course developer of the Product Capability Uplift. In this role, Anubhav leads the development of the PMA as well as works as the product thinker of the Product Capability Uplift PMA.


Anubhav Sinha is a product coach, a product management practitioner and technology product geek with around one and half decade of the product management and development experience that ranges widely in the B2B and B2IB product space. He is known for contributing and creating products majorly in the start-up space, helping start-ups in their early stages and contributing industry product organisations as user-experience flow optimiser. He had served industry as Principal Product Owner [co-founder], Product and Design Thinking Coach, Product Owner and Transformation Coach.


Anubhav holds a Post-Graduation in Marketing - IB and Bachelor of Engineering in Electrical and Electronics.


Comments


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page